Spoliation cases

South African case law on Spoliation, with full citations. 143 cases — page 1 of 1.

  1. Adlecraft Investments (Private) Limited v Cassandra Myburgh and Colins BakerHH 538-21, HC 4465/21
  2. Allied Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Trustees of Witfield Ridge Body CorporateCSOS 4861GP23 (Adjudication Order, 14 August 2023)
  3. Anthonie Christopher Lombard v Fort Hare University and Minister of PoliceCase No. 154/2024 (ECM)
  4. Anthony Mutaku Pachena v Francisca NyamukapaHH 557-25 (HCH 4659/25)
  5. Apatron Mining Private Limited and Matilda Mlotshwa v Patrick Hove and Meltrix Private LimitedJudgment No. HB 149/13, Case No. HC 1924/12
  6. Apostolic Faith Mission in Zimbabwe v Cossam ChiangwaHH 21-22, HC 6465/21 (Ref Case No. SC 433/21, HC 5549/21)
  7. Arnold Musengi Jhamba and Others v City of GweruHH 474-14, HC 9971/13
  8. Barbara Kasekera Nyabawa v Onias Gotora and Sheriff of ZimbabweHH 633-18, HC 7584/18
  9. Barbra Munava N.O. and Woodlane Family Trust v Francis Roland HaisaidHH 37-20, HC 42/20
  10. Barzani 53 CC v Trustees of Whitfield Ridge Body CorporateCSOS4486/GP/23 (Adjudication Order, 8 August 2023)
  11. Base Minerals Zimbabwe (Private) Limited and Others v Mabwe Minerals (Private) LimitedJudgment No. SC 29/15, Civil Case No. SC 136/14
  12. Bechan and Another v SARS Customs Investigations Unit and Others(1196/2022) [2024] ZASCA 20 (05 March 2024)
  13. Benson Mudangandi v Chartwell Matizanadzo and OthersHH 442/22 (HC 7273/21 and HC 398/22)
  14. Bethlehem Apostolic Church and Bishop Zacharia Caleb Gemu N.O v Rephio Chirumbwa and OthersHH 516-18, HC 3131/18
  15. Binga Estates (Private) Limited v Bvunzo Ancerimo and Elias Chibaya and Maclean Mahuva and 11 Others and Minister of Lands, Land Reform & ResettlementHH 370-17, HC 415/14
  16. Blanket Mine (1983) (Pvt) Ltd v Fisani Moyo and OthersHB 160/21, HC 895/21
  17. Blendrite (Pty) Ltd and Another v Moonisami and Another(227/2020) [2021] ZASCA 77
  18. Blesan Systems (Private) Limited t/a Avery Sports Bar v Cleopas Mabhena and Gabriel Real EstateHH 646-22, HC 5223/22
  19. Blue Rangers Estates (Pvt) Ltd v (1) Jamaya Muduviri (2) The Minister of Lands and Rural ResettlementJudgment No. 29/09, Civil Appeal No. 56/09
  20. Brian Davies v Floyd Ambrose and The Officer Commanding Zimbabwe Republic Police – Matabeleland North ProvinceHB 67/21, HC 105/21
  21. Carrowmore Investments (Pvt) Ltd v Mogola Enterprises (Pvt) Ltd and OthersHigh Court of Zimbabwe, Harare, 25 September 2012 (unreported)
  22. Cassandra Myburgh and Colin Baker v Adlecraft Investments (Private) LimitedSC 118/22 (Civil Appeal No. SC 360/21)
  23. Cathrine Moyo (in her capacity as Executrix Dative of the Estate of the Late Hadson Moyo) N.O. v Josman Chikahwi and OthersHB 112/18, HC 1160/18
  24. Charles Chiwaya v Ceaser Julious Manyunyi and OthersHMT 8-22, HC 35/22
  25. Chimurenga Mining Syndicate and Nathan Tendai Manyuchi and Dauglas Mahiya v Nomatter Nyarugwe and OthersHCMTJ11-26, HCMTC55/26
  26. Christopher Harly Brace Macquire and Twairob Investments (Pvt) Limited v Munyaradzi Tichaona and Bernard Mahara MutangaHH 258/13, HC 6131/13
  27. Christopher Moyo v Obert ChinhamoJudgment No. HB 111/11, Case No. HC 1647/11
  28. Church of the Province of Central Africa and Board of Trustees for the Diocese of Manicaland and Musiwa Mwashita v Elson Madoda Jakazi and OthersHH 238-11, HC 9664/11
  29. Claudius Jonga Kamangira v Justin Gweshe and OthersHH 473-15, HC 4347/15
  30. CMAL Private Limited v Kumbirai Kangai and Quicklink Investments Private Limited and The Sheriff of ZimbabweHH 223-22, HC 1067/22
  31. Confidence Mining Private Limited v Tianboa Mineral Industry Private Limited and OthersHH 15-22, HC 11223/18
  32. Consilia Chinanzvavana v The Commissioner General of the Zimbabwe Revenue Authority and The Zimbabwe Revenue AuthorityHH 743-22, HC 1014/22
  33. Cranrid Investments (Private) Limited v Macsherp (Private) LimitedHH 274-22, HC 5289/21
  34. Croco Motors (Pvt) Ltd v Redan Petroleum (Pvt) Ltd t/a Puma Petroleum and Total Zimbabwe (Pvt) LtdHH 752-15 (HC 8255/15 and HC 8272/15)
  35. Deborah Susan Bennett v Rodney Allen Bennett and OthersHH 06-22, HC 6530/21
  36. Dennegeur Estate Home Owners Association and Vodacom (Pty) Ltd v Telkom SA Soc Ltd(366/2018) [2019] ZASCA 37 (29 March 2019)
  37. D.G.L. Investments Number Two (Pvt) Ltd v Vongaishe Mupereri MP and OthersHB 64-18, HC 662/18
  38. Douglas Mamvura and Hedgehold Trading (Pvt) Limited t/a Mana Brand and Grosma Investments (Pvt) Limited v Israel Tangwena and OthersHH 371-14, HC 5819/14
  39. Duly Huni v George Pedzisai FichaniHH 275-22; HC 4156/21
  40. Elliot Mlalazi v Ernest Green and Officer in Charge, Zimbabwe Republic Police, InyathiHC 360/17, HC 2945/17
  41. Eric Thembalethu Joka v Station Commander, Vehicle Identification Unit, Komani and AnotherCase no. 2685/2025 (unreported, Eastern Cape Division, Makhanda)
  42. Eskom Holdings SOC Limited v Nomajapan Masinda(1225/2018) [2019] ZASCA 98 (18 June 2019)
  43. Estate Late Dereck Ronald Hill v Rutendo Chasi and OthersHB 165-17, HC 1510-17
  44. Estate Late Godfrey Havatitye Sigobodhla and Terttu Elisabet Sigobodhla v Takawira Chawonza and Minister of Lands Agriculture Fisheries Water and Rural ResettlementHH 515-21, HC 4379/21
  45. Evans Tapfumaneyi Munyati v Godfrey MugayiJudgment No SC 17/13, Civil Appeal No SC 230/11
  46. Everton Masau v Sheila Mabasa and Tineyi ChangundumaHH 393-17, HC 4192/17
  47. Exmin Syndicate v Luke Dube and OthersHB 102/22, HC 468/22
  48. Falcon Junior School v Hatfield Presbyterian ChurchHH 71-14, HC 324/14
  49. Farai Ndemera v The Sheriff of Zimbabwe and OthersHH 172-14, HC2547/14
  50. Feature Phiri and Others v Lovemilk Gwati and OthersHH 298-19, HC 3320/19
  51. Forbes & Thompson (Bulawayo) (Pvt) Ltd v The Zimbabwe National Water Authority and Timothy KadyamusumaHB 154-16, HC 1148-16
  52. Forrester Estate (Private) Limited v M.C.R. Vengesayi and The Minister of Lands in the Office of the President and CabinetHH 19-2010, HC 4362/09
  53. Forrester Estate (Pvt) Limited v Edgar ChidavaenziHH 22-2010, HC 202/010
  54. Gibson Boston Siziba v Thabani Mpabanga and Bafokazana MasukuHB 78-16 (HC 08-16)
  55. Gibson Chamboko and Mr Chamboko Snr and Change Tomas Kwodzi v Patric John Stooks and P J Stooks (Private) LimitedHH 122-10, HC 2224/09
  56. Gramara Enterprises (Pvt) Ltd and Colin Bailie Cloete v The Minister of State for National Security Responsible for Land, Land Reform and Resettlement and Mr Norman KapangaHH 50-09, HC 6396/08
  57. Harland Brothers (Pvt) Limited and Raymond Finaughty v The Minister of Lands and Rural Resettlement and Mrs Winnie MushipeHH 6-2010, HC 6521/09
  58. Heather Guild v Fungai Cheruka and The Minister of Lands and Rural ResettlementHH488-13, HC9533/13
  59. Herbert Mutasa v Stanley Mtetwa and Natsai BvirakureHH 168-18, HC 500/18
  60. Holam Mining (Pvt) Ltd and Chen Shaoling v Benwise Investments (Pvt) Ltd and Jameson RushwayaHH 244-16, HC 2757/16
  61. Hunyani Forests Limited v Buywest Investments Private LimitedHH 105/21, HC 141/21 (Ref HC 7094/20, Ref HC 4051/20, Ref SC 371/20, Ref SC 484/20)
  62. Impala Enterprises (Pvt) Ltd t/a Filibeg Investments (Pvt) Ltd v Tracy Nyathi a.k.a Tracy Monzeyiwa and OthersHB 13/26; HCBC 128/26
  63. Infinity Car Sales and Others v First Turn Investments t/a Shar Car Sales and AnotherHB 65/20; HCA 14/19
  64. Isaac Tamuka Mahachi v Zondiwa Nyamande and OthersHH 337/22, HC 3073/22
  65. Jamal Ahmed and Others v Russel Goreraza and OthersHH 402-17, HC 12497/16
  66. Johanes Faurie v Andrew MachihaHH 486-13, HC 2975/12
  67. John Nigel Orsborne v H Shumbamhini and Minister of Lands and Rural ResettlementHH 234/16, HC 1232/16
  68. John Percival Bawden v Thulani Ndebele and Sikhumbuzo MpofuJudgment No. HB 110/11, Case No. HC2006/08
  69. John Strong (Private) Limited and Tobs Strong (Private) Limited v William Wachenuka and Ministry of Lands, Agriculture and ResettlementHH 118-10, HC 1916/09
  70. Josephat Hatidikani Kevin Sachikonye v Korbs Mutandiro and OthersHH 475-17, HC 5949/17
  71. Karori (Private) Limited and Charles Ingram Lock v Brigadier MujajiHH 23-2007, HC 824/07
  72. Kershelmar Farms (Pvt) Ltd and Others v Dumisani MadzivanyatiHB 224/21, HC 1532/21 (XREF SCB 53/21, XREF HC 1315/21)
  73. Kershelmar Farms (Pvt) Ltd and Others v Dumisani MadzivanyatiHB 190/21, HC 1315/21
  74. Kershelmar Farms (Pvt) Ltd and Others v Mswelangubo Farms (Pvt) Ltd and OthersHB 39/22 (HC 2031/21, XREF SCB 69/21, XREF HC 1917/21)
  75. Komborerai Nhenga aka Chapungu v Ephert Saka and Egesi GarepiHB 44-17 (HC 267-17 & HC 303-17)
  76. Lehlabi v Trustees of Soldonne Village Body CorporateCSOS-15120-GP-23 (Adjudication Order, 28 March 2024)
  77. Loskop Landgoed Boerdery (Pty) Ltd and Others v Petrus Moeleso and Others[2022] ZASCA 53 (12 April 2022)
  78. L.S Waters (Pvt) Ltd and Johannes Jakobus Laubscher v Zimbabwe National Water Authority and OthersHH 153/16, HC 1401/16
  79. Lydmo Cleaning Services v Dairiboard Zimbabwe (Pvt) LtdHH 277-15, HC 2438/15
  80. Lysias Chiturumani and Wellington Maraire v Anderson PhiriHH 430-14, HC 6769/14
  81. Mabwe Minerals (Private) Limited v Base Mineral Zimbabwe and OthersHH 119-14, HC 1549/14
  82. Mahlangu v Trustees of Greencreek Lifestyle Body Corporate and Midcity Property ManagementCSOS-13447/GP/23 (Adjudication Order, 22 February 2024)
  83. Mahomed Salim Dawood v Trustees of Rynsoord Village Body CorporateCSOS-13480-GP-23 (Adjudication Order, 13 March 2024)
  84. Makandi Estate (Private) Limited v Temba Sithole and 10 OthersHMT 20-22, HC 287/21
  85. Marinda Fenesey v Gateway Primary School and KM Ricquebourg N.O. and Gateway Primary School Parents Association and The Sheriff of ZimbabweHH 329-17, HC 4249/17
  86. Mario Damani v Waterbessie Investments (Pvt) Limited and OthersHH 173-26; HCH-3888/25
  87. Marry Mubaiwa-Chiwenga v Constantino Guvheya Dominic Nyikadzino ChiwengaHH 74-20, HC 127/20
  88. Mbashe Diocese of the Anglican Church v Mayapi and OthersCase No: 5243/2024 (High Court of South Africa, Eastern Cape Division, Mthatha)
  89. Modikwa Platinum Mine, an unincorporated joint venture between Rustenburg Platinum Mines Limited and Arm Mining Consortium Limited v Nkwe Platinum Limited and Others(1333/2021) [2023] ZASCA 08 (06 February 2023)
  90. Monica Mugova and Edwell Mugova v Stanley Mwase and Wonderful Sedeya and Robert MusvosviHH 621-22, HC 6006/22
  91. Mswelangubo Farm (Private) Limited and Others v Kershelmar Farms (Private) Limited and OthersJudgment No. SC 80/22, Civil Appeal No. SCB 69/21
  92. Mudiwa Mining Syndicate v San He Mining and OthersHH 458-25, HC 3493/24
  93. Muhanelwa v Gcingca[2019] ZACC 21
  94. Mukuvisi Tashinga Housing Co-Operative (Represented by Catherine Kudambo) v Danny Musukuma and OthersHH 478-15, HC 4509/15
  95. Mveleli VA v King Sabata Dalindyebo MunicipalityCase No.: 2025/117610 (unreported)
  96. Ngoni Edward Mutopo v Mupfurutsi Game Park and Power Mupunga N.OHH 408-19, HC 4384/19
  97. Ngoni Manyika and Others v Fungai Fredy and OthersHH 561-22, CIV "A" 94/22, CASE No app 57/22
  98. Nomatter Nyarugwe v Chimurenga Mining Syndicate and OthersHCMTJ6-26; HCMTC 26/26
  99. Nontokozo Moyo v Amanda Falala and OthersHB 87/25; HCBC 469/25
  100. Norwich Trading (Pvt) Ltd v Astrodorne Enterprises (Pvt) LtdHH 716-22; HC 1479/21 (Ref Case HC 912/21)
  101. Nyamande Mining Syndicate v Munyukwa Chibanda and Provincial Mining Director Mashonaland East N.O.HH 460-21, HC 4116/21
  102. Nyasha Chikafu v Dodhill (Pvt) Ltd and OthersHH 41-2009, HC 1028/09
  103. Obert Chanika v Mining Commissioner N.O. and Darwin Mining Syndicate and Wycliff Evon GatawaHH (unreported, High Court of Zimbabwe, 21 March 2012)
  104. Oliver Masomera N.O and Savanna Africa Holdings (Private) Limited [Under Provisional Judicial Management] v Tamani Investments (Private) Limited and OthersHH 83-18, HC 11316/18
  105. Overflow Zone Enterprises (Pvt) Ltd v Owden Nhimura and OthersHH 166-22, HC 8108/17
  106. Panki Mbongozi v Mac Mkunyana InvestmentsCase No: 135/2023 (Eastern Cape Division: Mthatha)
  107. Patrick John Stooks and P.J Stooks (Pvt) Ltd v Jonathan Chamboko and Gibson Chamboko and Chance Thomas RwodziHH (High Court Harare) - judgment delivered 9 November 2010 (reasons delivered 3 December 2010)
  108. Patrick Muregwi v Northside Community Church and Messenger of CourtHH 156-20, HC 808/20
  109. Peter Pedzisai and 24 Others v Hope Werekenai Katuka and Sheriff of ZimbabweHH 102-22, HC 5235/21
  110. Philemon Mutangiri and Others v Leonard Mutema t/a Leonard Trading and AnotherHMA 06-18, Case No HC 273/17
  111. Phillip S Rankin v Sylvester Nyatsuro and OthersHH 9-16, HC 12579/15
  112. Pickglow Trading (Private) Limited v Country Petrolium (Private) Limited t/a Glow Petrolium and OthersHH (unreported) - High Court of Zimbabwe, Harare, 23 April 2012 & 27 June 2012
  113. Premier Auto Services (Pvt) Ltd v Clear Choice Logistics (Pvt) Ltd & OrsHH 294-21, HC 2818/21
  114. Q and Q Transport (Pty) Ltd v Edan Traders (Pty) LtdCase No: 2025-120339 (Eastern Cape Division, Gqeberha)
  115. Redan Petroleum Private Limited and Spring and Autumn Private Limited v Shumba Holdings Private Limited and OthersHH 358-16, HC 4576/16
  116. Ricnob Suppliers (Private) Limited and Alfred Chinanayi v Mike Mandizera and Minister of Mines and Mineral DevelopmentHB 262-18, HC 5563/18, XREF HC 1755/18
  117. Rita Marque Mbatha v Vincent Ncube and Messenger of Court, HarareHH 648-21, HC 5701/21
  118. Rita Marque Mbatha v Vincent Ncube and Messenger of Court, HarareSC 109/22; Civil Appeal No. SC 443/21
  119. R.R Estates (Private) Limited and Colin Bruce Nienbar v Henry Nyikadzino and Tafadzwa NyikadzinoHH 435-17, HC 5728/17
  120. Saddam Mustafa Rashidi v Trondel Investments (Private) Limited and OthersHH 649-25; HCH 5168/25
  121. Save Safaris (Pvt) Ltd v H.J. Vorster (Pvt) Ltd and OthersHB 173/21, HC 1140/21
  122. Shaillon Chiswa v Maxess Marketing (Pvt) Ltd and OthersHH 116-20, HC 430/20
  123. Silence Sibindi (Represented by Job Bernard Sibindi) and Pwiseyi Nhamoinesu v The Messenger of Court, Gweru N.O.HMA 53-21; CIV 'A' 39-20
  124. Snack House (Pvt) Ltd v Stanley ChiwesheHH 201/22; HC 6571/20
  125. Strauss Logistics Zimbabwe (Private) Limited v Gift Abraham and 199 OthersHH 618-22, HC 4845/22
  126. Sweet Sweet v Jonathan Nkanyenzi and OthersHB 173-16, HC 1294-14, XREF HC 2459-08
  127. Talkmore Chigeza v Assistant Commissioner Mvere and OthersHH 487-14, HC 3068/14
  128. Tasip Mining Syndicate and Others v William Savanhu and OthersHH 157-22; HC 6291/21
  129. Tebogo Motsai v The Executive Committee of Munyaka Homeowners Association and Elgaru WaterfallCSOS-92/GP/23 (Adjudication Order, 19 December 2023)
  130. Telkom SA Limited v Xsinet (Proprietary) LimitedCase No. 92/2002 (SCA) [2003]; Xsinet (Pty) Ltd v Telkom SA Ltd 2002 (3) SA 629 (C)
  131. Trevor Gifford v I. Mugomba and OthersHH 135-10, HC 4236/10
  132. Trustees of the S.O.S. Children's Village Association of Zimbabwe v Bindura University and OthersHH349-14, HC 4813/14
  133. Trynos Nkomo v Sifanjani Moyo and OthersHB 265/16, HC 2309/16
  134. Umguza Community Share Ownership Trust v Obert Mpofu and OthersHB 124/18; HC 1438/18
  135. Varlerie Paidamoyo Madanire v Maria MafungaHH 596-21, HC 5344/21
  136. Wagendrift Safaries (Pty) Ltd v M P Shlemembe and The Shelembe CommunityLCC22/2010
  137. Wightman v Headfour (Pty) Ltd(66/2007) [2008] ZASCA 6 (10 March 2008)
  138. Wild Goose Safaris (Pvt) Ltd v Sipho Mpofu and OthersJudgment No. HB 19/12, Case No. HC 348/11
  139. Wistmer Investments (Pvt) Limited v Nyashanu Mining Syndicate and OthersHH 209-22, HC 1277/22
  140. Zakeyo Mereki v Bell Inn (Private) Limited and OthersHH 11-2006, HC 79/2006
  141. Zaleekhah Islam v Yusuf Abdul Karim JoomaHH 624-21, HC 74/21
  142. Zenzele Sibanda v Peter J. Buckle and OthersHB 49/17, HC 544/17
  143. Zimbabwe Parents of Handicapped Children Association v Grimms Nursery School and OthersJudgment No. HB 73/12, Case No. HC 682/12