CaseNotes LogoCaseNotes
  • Home
  • Library
  • Research
  • Discussion Hub
  • Wiki
  • Latin Dictionary
  • Question Bank
  • Settings
S

Student

Student Account

South African Law • Jurisdictional Corpus
HomeLibraryResearchQuestionsSettings
Judicial Precedent
Ask AI

Pretorius v Trustees of Ponders End Body Corporate and Earth Zone Properties

CitationCSOS 7586/GP/22 (Adjudication Order, 03 June 2024)
JurisdictionZA
Area of Law
Community Schemes LawSectional Titles Law
Free account

Get the most out of this judgment

Create a free CaseNotes account to save this case, see how it's cited, get an AI summary, and search 10,000+ SA judgments.

Create free accountor sign in
Administrative/Statutory Adjudication
Financial Levies and Body Corporate Contributions

Facts of the Case

James Pretorius, the registered owner of unit 61 in the Ponders End sectional title scheme, brought an application to the Community Schemes Ombud Service under section 38 of the Community Schemes Ombud Service Act 9 of 2011. He complained that legal fees had been debited to his levy account by the body corporate's managing agent, Earth Zone Properties, and sought an order under section 39(1)(c) declaring the contribution unreasonable or incorrectly determined. He asked that the legal fees be removed and that an appropriate payment plan be arranged for his arrears. The respondents stated that Pretorius had not paid levies since 2021, that the account was handed to attorneys for debt collection, and that the body corporate had a valid AGM-approved resolution authorising recovery of legal costs from defaulting owners and debiting those costs to their levy accounts. The legal fees in issue totalled R12 572.95. The respondents also indicated willingness to consider a reasonable payment plan, although none had yet been agreed.

Legal Issues

  • Whether the body corporate was entitled to debit the applicant's levy account with legal fees incurred in collecting arrear levies.
  • Whether the legal fees of R12 572.95 were incorrectly determined or unreasonable for purposes of section 39(1)(c) of the CSOS Act.
  • Whether a CSOS adjudicator has jurisdiction under section 39 of the CSOS Act to order the parties to enter into a payment arrangement.

Judicial Outcome

The application was dismissed. The adjudicator refused all relief sought by the applicant, including removal of the legal fees and an order compelling a payment plan. No order as to costs was made.

Ratio Decidendi

A sectional title owner is liable, under PMR 25(4), for reasonable legal costs and disbursements incurred by the body corporate in collecting arrear levies, and where the scheme has validly resolved that such costs are recoverable and may be debited to the owner's levy account, the owner is bound by that resolution. Further, a CSOS adjudicator may grant only relief authorised by section 39 of the CSOS Act; relief falling outside that section, such as compelling the conclusion of a payment agreement, is beyond the adjudicator's jurisdiction.

Obiter Dicta

The adjudicator observed that the respondents were willing to engage with the applicant regarding a reasonable payment arrangement and noted that, once such a plan is in place, penalty interest and legal fees would cease to accrue. This was not part of the binding order. The adjudicator also remarked generally that scheme members are reasonably expected to know resolutions taken at general or trustees' meetings.

Legal Significance

The decision is significant in community schemes and sectional title governance because it confirms that, where supported by PMR 25(4) and a valid scheme resolution, a body corporate may recover reasonable legal costs incurred in collecting arrear levies from a defaulting owner and debit those costs to the owner's levy account. It also reinforces the jurisdictional limits of CSOS adjudicators: they may grant only remedies falling within section 39 of the CSOS Act and cannot compel parties to conclude payment agreements if such relief is not statutorily authorised.

Cited By 1850 Cases

  • (1) Douglas Tanyanyiwa (2) Douglas Warriors Football Club v Lawrence Bernard GwaradaCivil Appeal No. SC 150/11; Judgment No. SC 79/2014
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court (Ziyambi JA, Gowora JA, Guvava JA) dismissed the appeal with costs. The Court found no misdirection by the High Court and held that the lower…

  • (1) Isador Husaiwevhu (2) Walter Mutowo (3) Fungai Zinyama v (1) UZ-UCSF Collaborative Research Programme (2) Sheriff of Zimbabwe N.O (3) High Court Registrar N.OJudgment No. SC 86/25, Civil Appeal No. SC 302/25
    Appeal From

    Gowora J (as she then was) granted the appellants' application to register the quantified arbitral award, resulting in a judgment debt of US$788,296.21 in…

  • (1) Tungamirai Madzokere (2) Lazarus Maengahama (3) Stanford Maengahama (4) Phineous Nhatarikwa (5) Stanford Mangwiro (6) Yvonne Musarurwa (7) Rebecca Mafukeni v The StateSC 8/12; Civil Application No. 318/11
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court allowed the appeal on 13 February 2012. The Deputy Chief Justice found that the High Court had misdirected itself by failing to apply the…

  • A. Adam and Company (Private) Limited & 2 Others v Good Living Real Estate (Private) Limited

Practice This Case

Sign up to practise IRAC analysis, issue spotting, and argument building on this case.

SC 50/21; Civil Appeal No. SC 351/19
Appeal From

The Supreme Court found that the arbitrator acted contrary to public policy by issuing the final award in defiance of Chigumba J's binding order, which he…

  • Aaron Mwenje v Intermarket Building SocietySC. 80/05 (Civil Appeal No. 358/04)
    Appeal From

    Mwenje appealed the Labour Court's dismissal of his application. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal with costs on 21 July 2005, agreeing with the Senior…

  • Abbott v Overstrand Municipality(99/2015) [2016] ZASCA 68
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal with costs including the costs of two counsel. The court held that the appellant failed to prove that the…

  • Abednico Bhebhe and Others v The Chairman of Zimbabwe Electoral Commission N.O. and OthersJudgment No. HB 139/11, Case No. HC 1485/10
    Appeal From

    The High Court granted the application, ordering the 3rd respondent (President) to gazette election dates within fourteen days for the three vacant…

  • Abednico Bhebhe v Lupane State UniversityHB 25-18; HC 2873/17
    Appeal From

    Moyo J dismissed the urgent chamber application with costs. The court held that the applicant failed to establish a prima facie right as he was never granted…

  • Abednico Tsamwise v Minister of Lands, Agriculture, Water, Climate and Rural Settlement and Wellington Maruma and Zimbabwe Land CommissionHH 705-22, HC 801/22
    Appeal From

    The High Court declined to exercise its jurisdiction on the grounds that the applicant had not exhausted domestic remedies provided under the Land Commission…

  • Absalom Nganunu Sibanda v Na Jing Zhou Resources Africa (Private) LimitedHH 510-16, HC 12423/15
    Appeal From

    The High Court considered the applicant's application for registration and enforcement of the arbitration award in terms of Article 35 of the Model Law. The…

  • A B v Zimbabwe Revenue Authority (ZIMRA)HH 479-21 (ITC 5/21)
    Appeal From

    MAFUSIRE J heard the application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court on 20 July 2021 and dismissed it on 13 September 2021. The court found the proposed…

  • ACCA Zimbabwe v Cuthbert MunhupedziHH 232-21, HC 3522/20
    Appeal From

    The High Court granted the applicant's rei vindicatio application filed on 9 July 2020, ordering the respondent to deliver two motor vehicles to the applicant…

  • Ackim Mita Dibae v The StateJudgment No. S.C. 213/98, Crim. Appeal No. 194/97
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal against both conviction and sentence in its entirety. The Court found that the audit evidence established blatant…

  • Actual Protective Clothing (Pvt) Ltd t/a Actual Transport v Bulk Commodities (Pvt) Ltd and OthersHB 118-15 (HC 2461-14)
    Appeal From

    Takuva J dismissed the respondents' points in limine and opposition on the merits. The court found that the applicant had established clear ownership rights…

  • Adendorffs Boerderye (Pty) Ltd v Fayindolo Shabalala & others(997/15) [2017] ZASCA 37 (29 March 2017)
    Appeal From

    The SCA (Mathopo JA, with Shongwe, Majiedt, Van der Merwe JJA and Mbatha AJA concurring) found that the LCC had erred by granting orders not pleaded or sought…

  • Adlecraft (Private) Limited v Liberation Mining (Pvt) LimitedHH 379-22, HC 563/21
    Appeal From

    Chitapi J granted a rei-vindicatio order in favor of the respondent (Liberation Mining) on 17 January 2020. The court found that the purported agreement of…

  • Adolf Ndudzo v The StateHH 171-15, CA 315/14, CRB 6698/13
    Appeal From

    The High Court (Chatukuta and Mangota JJ) allowed the appeal in part. The court found that the trial magistrate had seriously misdirected itself by failing to…

  • Adrian Zvivada and Last Mhlatini and Farai Hakamera v The StateHH 207-22, HC B 1925/21
    Appeal From

    The High Court (Foroma J) dismissed the appeal against the refusal of bail. While the court found that the Magistrates Court had made an irregularity in its…

  • Aepromm Resources (Pvt) Ltd v Samuel Mazowe and OthersHH 192-2010; HC 5715/10
    Appeal From

    Mtshiya J dismissed the applicant's second urgent application seeking an interdict pending the appeal. The court held it had no power to review the earlier…

  • Afesi Mkhweli v Shingirai Marufu and Postal and Regulatory Authority of ZimbabweHB 51-19, HC 1169-18
    Appeal From

    The High Court granted the defendants' application for absolution from the instance with costs against the plaintiff. Moyo J found that the plaintiff failed to…

  • AFM In Zimbabwe v Josiah GaramukanwaHH 468-17, HC 1071/13
    Appeal From

    The High Court heard the rei vindicatio application brought by the applicant seeking to evict the respondent from church property. After appointing a curator…

  • Afrasia Bank Limited v K. S. Trust and Master of the High CourtSC 39/18, Civil Appeal No. SC 796/16
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court (Guvava JA, Uchena JA & Ziyambi AJA) heard the appeal by Afrasia Bank Limited against the High Court's order. The Court dismissed the appeal…

  • African Gold (Zimbabwe) (Private) Limited v Modest (Private) LimitedS.C. 79/99
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court allowed the appeal with costs, holding that compliance with Rule 5(2) of the Companies (Winding Up) Rules requiring prior service of the…

  • Africa Tribune Newspapers (Pvt) Ltd and Others v The Media and Information Commission and AnotherHH 139-2004, HC 7612/04
    Appeal From

    The High Court reviewed the Commission's decision on urgent application filed 17 June 2004. Uchena J found that the Commission committed an irregularity in…

  • Agricultural and Rural Development Authority v Francis Baureni and 18 OthersJudgment No. SC 16/2019, Case No. SC 284/18
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal with costs. It found that the Board properly responded within the statutory 14-day period, that 'respond' does not mean…

  • Aguy Clement Georgias & Another v Zimbabwe Development Bank Financial Services LimitedS.C. 115/2001 (Civil Appeal No. 385/2000)
    Appeal From

    The High Court dismissed the appellants' application for a refund of $739,688.18, which they claimed was an overpayment made under a bank guarantee. The court…

  • (A) ICL Zimbabwe Limited v (1) The Taxing Master, Supreme Court (2) Amos Mwatsaka; (B) Amos Mwatsaka v (1) ICL Zimbabwe Limited (2) The Taxing Master, Supreme CourtS.C. 45/99 (Civil Appeal Nos. 661/94 & 82/98)
    Appeal From

    Both parties brought review applications under Rule 48(2) challenging the Taxing Officer's decisions. McNally JA heard both reviews together. He upheld certain…

  • Alagonia Farming (Private) Limited and Others v Northern Tobacco (Private) Limited and OthersHH 72-14 (HC 75/13, HH 484/13, HC 9919/13, HC 10247/13, HC 10261/13, HC 10802/13)
    Appeal From

    Hungwe J granted Bright Ziyanga's urgent application seeking an order staying Tsanga J's order and rescission of the judgment on the basis that although the…

  • Albert Mavhiya v The StateHH 731-22, HACC (A) 05/21
    Appeal From

    The High Court (Chikowero and Kwenda JJ) dismissed the appeal against conviction. The appellant had abandoned the appeal against sentence at the hearing. The…

  • Albert Mugove Matapo and Others v The StateHH 48-2010; HC 709-14/07
    Appeal From

    The High Court (Makarau JP) dismissed the consolidated bail applications filed by the applicants after the Constitutional Court ruling. Despite the systemic…

  • Albert Tewende and Queensdale Mining (Private) Limited v Evelyn Mupandawana, Philip Takudzwa Mupandawana, and Mining Commissioner Kadoma/Provincial Mining Director Mashonaland West ProvinceJudgment No. SC 100/25; Chamber Application No. SC 713/25
    Appeal From

    The applicants filed a fresh application for condonation of non-compliance with Rule 45(1) and for extension of time to note an appeal. The Supreme Court…

  • Alexio Mandisodza v Angeline ZvaraiHH 823-18, HC 1889/18
    Appeal From

    The applicant sought review of the Magistrate's decision on grounds that he was denied the opportunity to call witnesses and that the Magistrate erred in…

  • Alfred Chaavure v Old Mutual Zimbabwe Limited and Registrar of CompaniesHH 526-17; HC 1670/17
    Appeal From

    The High Court (Chiweshe JP) dismissed the first defendant's exception in its entirety. The court found that the plaintiff's summons and declaration…

  • Alfred Kushamisa Mwazha & 9 Others v Ernest MhambareJudgment No. SC 116/21, Civil Appeal No. SC 552/20
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court partially allowed the appeal. It upheld paragraphs 1 and 2 of the High Court's order finding the first appellant's nomination…

  • Alfred Zvapera and Faith Ngwenyenyi v The StateHB 61-17, HCB 35-17
    Appeal From

    The High Court heard the bail application. The State consented to bail for the second applicant, Faith Ngwenyenyi, who was granted bail. The first applicant,…

  • Alistair Michael Fletcher v Minister of Lands Agriculture, Fisheries, Water & Rural Development N.O and OthersJudgment No. CCZ 14/25, Constitutional Application No. CCZ 19/24
    Appeal From

    The Constitutional Court allowed the appeal. It held that the land in question was urban land (having been proclaimed as such by S.I. 212 of 1999), that…

  • Al Jazeera Media Network v Mehluleli DubeJudgment No. SC 113/25, Civil Appeal No. SC 124/25
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court allowed the appeal with costs and set aside the High Court's judgment. The Court held that the High Court erred in finding that the appellant…

  • Allaclas Investments (Pty) Ltd & Another v Milnerton Golf Club & Others[2007] 167 SCA (RSA); Case number 673/06
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court of Appeal upheld the appeal with costs, finding that the high incidence of badly aimed golf balls entering the appellants' property was…

  • Allan Norman Markham and Tavonga Savings Scheme and Jacob Pikicha v Augur Investments OU and Kenneth Raydon Sharpe and Tatiana Aleshina and Michael John Van Blerk and City of Harare and The Minister of Local Government, Public Works and National Housing and Doorex Properties (Pvt) Ltd and Registrar of Deeds and The President of the Republic of ZimbabweHH 296-22, HC 425/2021
    Appeal From

    The City of Harare successfully challenged the arbitral award before Muremba J on 10 August 2018. The court set aside the arbitral award granted by Mtshiya J.

  • Allied Bank Limited v Celeb Dengu and Wilson Tendai NyabondaJudgment No. SC 52/2016, Civil Appeal No. SC 503/15
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court allowed the appeal with costs. It held that the High Court erred in: (1) accepting an improperly pleaded special plea; (2) finding that locus…

  • Allied Regent Trading CC v Stanley MoyoHH 255-26, HCHC344-25
    Appeal From

    On 26 November 2025, Mafusire J granted an order for civil imprisonment against the defendant for 90 days, suspended on condition that he pay the plaintiff the…

  • Alpha Moyo Maphenduka v Jonathan Maphenduka and Assistant Master, High Court, BulawayoJudgment No. 104/13, Case No. HC 2713/12, Xref No. 663/05 & 915/05
    Appeal From

    On 27 June 2013, CHEDA J dismissed the applicant's application for condonation of late filing of a rescission application with costs. The court found that the…

  • Alphonsus Obioma Achinulo v W. Maphios Moyo N.O and The StateHB 226-16, HC 1755-16
    Appeal From

    The applicant sought an urgent stay of the criminal proceedings pending the determination of the review application. Mathonsi J granted the provisional order,…

  • Al Shams Global BVI Limited v Deposit Protection Corporation and OthersJudgment No. SC 52/22, Civil Appeal No. SC 447/21
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court struck off the appeal on 23 May 2022, finding that the High Court's order was an interlocutory judgment that required leave to appeal under…

  • Alvestone Estate (1985) (Private) Limited v Tracy Mutinhiri and Honourable N. T. Mtshiya (Retired) N.O. (Arbitrator)HH 574-25, HC 7538/22
    Appeal From

    Mambara J granted the application in part, setting aside paragraphs 24(2) and 24(3) of the arbitral award under Article 34(2)(iii) of the Arbitration Act on…

  • Alvis Siyawamwaya v The StateHH 640-21, CA 506/20
    Appeal From

    The High Court dismissed the appeal against conviction. The court found that the first and third grounds of appeal were invalid as they were general and vague,…

  • Amanda Berkowitz (nee Cohen) and Waverley Plastics (Private) Limited v Aron Vico and AA Omar and Company and Registrar of Companies N.O.HH 231-21, HC 5040/19
    Appeal From

    The High Court (per Charewa J) heard the first defendant's special plea objecting to the declaration as a nullity for being filed out of time. The court found…

  • Amanda Muridzo and Others v Bianca Makwande and The StateHH 229-22; HC 4823/20; REF: HC 4906/20; REF: ACC 62-64/19
    Appeal From

    The applicants sought review of the regional magistrate's interlocutory decision to dismiss their discharge application. Chitapi J dismissed the review…

  • Amaplat Mauritius Limited and Others v Zimbabwe Mining Development Corporation and OthersHH 26-11; HC 506/11
    Appeal From

    Bhunu J refused to grant an interim interdict pending determination of the main urgent application for interim relief. The court held it was unnecessary to…

  • Ambassador Chimonyo v Route Toute BV and OthersHH 16-2010, HC 128/10
    Appeal From

    Patel J confirmed the provisional spoliation order on 21 December 2009. The order was declaratory in nature and pronounced that applicant had no right to…

  • American Friends Service Committee v Irene ChaukeJudgment No. 1/2012, Civil Appeal No. SC 9/11
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court upheld the Labour Court's finding that an employment relationship existed between the parties but set aside the damages award. The court…

  • Amidol Services (Private) Limited t/a House of Rag v Andrew ChepiriHH 257-26; HCH 2409/24
    Appeal From

    On appeal, the High Court (Mawadze DJP and Wamambo J) allowed the appeal, set aside the Magistrates' Court judgment, and upheld the special plea. The Court…

  • Amos Gwinya v The StateJudgment No. SC 82/22; Chamber Application No. SC 328/21
    Appeal From

    The Supreme Court granted leave to appeal against the High Court's judgment. The court found that the applicant had good prospects of success on appeal because…

  • Amos Makono & 32 Others v Freda Rebecca Gold MineHH 400-18, HC 5422/17
    Appeal From

    The applicants sought registration of the arbitral award under s 98(14) of the Labour Act. The respondent raised a preliminary point that the application was a…

  • Anatos Mpofu v Commissioner of Police and Police Services CommissionHH 08-2011, HC 9207/03
    Appeal From

    Following remittal from the Supreme Court, the High Court determined that reinstatement was inappropriate due to breakdown of the working relationship and…

  • Anderson Hamandishe and Matthew Hamandishe v Chirumhanzu Rural District Council and The Sheriff for Zimbabwe N.O.HH 382-25, HCH 2076/24
    Appeal From

    Manyangadze J upheld the first respondent's preliminary point that the applicants had failed to join persons who would be affected by the eviction and…

  • Andrew John Ehrke v The StateJudgment No. HB 30/14, Case No. HCA 219/12
    Appeal From

    The High Court (Kamocha and Makonese JJ) dismissed the appeal against both conviction and sentence. The court held that the Appellant fell within the…

  • Andrew Maloya v Rubbie Chitungo and Knowledge Mumanyi (In his capacity as Executor of the Estate Late Anderson Maloya) and Blessing Mazarura and Master of the High CourtHH 147-20, HC 1121/19
    Appeal From

    The High Court (Charewa J) dismissed the applicant's application for condonation of late filing of a review application with costs. The court found that the…

  • Andrew Maringa v Minister of Lands, Agriculture, Water, Climate and Rural Resettlement and Winray Estates (Pvt) LtdHH 527-22, HC 2754/20 (X-REF HC 9831/15, HC 5604/16)
    Appeal From

    The applicant brought a declaratory application under section 14 of the High Court Act seeking to be declared the lawful holder of the offer letter after the…

  • Andrew Muzamhindo v Zimbabwe CricketHH 720-18, HC 7584/17
    Appeal From

    On 17 August 2017, the plaintiff issued fresh summons claiming $30,962.52 (later amended to $25,400) as interest on the original award. The defendant excepted…

  • Explore More Cases

    More Community Schemes Law cases

    • 4-Tune Investments (Pty) Ltd v Kingsgate Body CorporateCSOS 4565/WC/22 (Adjudication Order, 29 November 2023)
    • 9 on Rydal Vale Court Body Corporate v Pan African Holdings Pty LtdCSOS-4563/KZN/23 (Adjudication Order, 8 November 2023)
    • Abrahm Bore v The Trustees of Loeries Park Body CorporateCSOS9164/GP/22 (Adjudication Order, 25 July 2022)
    • Agostini obo Firlands Park Home Owners' Association v Trustees for the time being of Rory Bamber TrustCSOS Adjudication Order Ref: CSOS7311/WC/23 (7 December 2023)
    • Ahmed Sadeck Mansoor obo Al Zakhura v Mont Blanc Body CorporateCSOS5288/KZN/22; adjudication order dated 13 January 2023
    • Akasia Body Corporate v Matodzi MukwevhoCSOS 10243/GP/23 (Adjudication Order, 11 April 2024)
    • Akasia Body Corporate v MF & H MashiyaCSOS 10233/GP/23 (Adjudication Order, 11 April 2024)
    • Akasia Body Corporate v RFL RodriquesCSOS 10242/GP/23 (Adjudication Order, 11 April 2024)

    More South Africa cases

    • 3M South Africa (Pty) Ltd v The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service(272/09) [2010] ZASCA 20 (23 March 2010)
    • 4 Seasons Logistics CC v Kgotse(1215/2023) [2026] ZASCA 09 (04 February 2026)
    • 4 Seasons Logistics CC v Nicholas Ngwanammoto Kgotse(1215/2023) [2026] ZASCA 09 (4 February 2026)
    • 4-Tune Investments (Pty) Ltd v Kingsgate Body CorporateCSOS 4565/WC/22 (Adjudication Order, 29 November 2023)
    • 68 Wolmarans Street Johannesburg (Pty) Ltd and Others v Tufh Limited(1263/2022) [2024] ZASCA 48 (15 April 2024)
    • 9 on Rydal Vale Court Body Corporate v Pan African Holdings Pty LtdCSOS-4563/KZN/23 (Adjudication Order, 8 November 2023)
    • AAA Investments (Proprietary) Limited v The Micro Finance Regulatory Council and Another
    2006 (11) BCLR 1255 (CC) (also reported as CCT 51/05)
  • A A Alloy Foundry (Pty) Limited v Titaco Projects (Pty) LimitedCase No. 309/97